QUOTE(DrAndy @ Feb 1 2009, 09:06 PM)

The last play of the game WAS a fumble. I agree that it should have been reviewed, but that's not getting reversed, so Pittsburgh did not benefit.
You can't run into the holder. That was an unfortunate break for the Cardinals, but it was a clear penalty. That's like running into the kicker. It's automatic.
As for the personal foul on the punt, I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure that unless it's roughing the kicker, once the ball leaves the punter's foot, penalties are now considered post change of possession. It doesn't matter if Pittsburgh touches to the punt or not. Some punts aren't fielded, as the receiving team just lets the ball roll. Any foul while that's going on counts towards the return, which is what happened.
The roughing the passer call was the only one I had an issue with. It was a little late, but it was soft, and should have been ignored. That lead to 3 points.
I don't necessarily disagree on the last play, but I thought it was inconclusive enough at the time to at least review it. Watching the replay, it was as borderline as it gets IMO. Warner was just starting the pass, but not quite enough to clearly overturn the call. I don't think it was "clearly" a fumble at all. And I wasn't really rooting for AZ. I wasn't rooting for anyone. Just enjoying an entertaining last quarter.
(Cigarette break, brb143lols)
I understand you can't run into the holder, but it's not like he was slammed to the ground. I don't disagree with that call a ton either, but if a guy isn't even in danger of getting hurt...why? During the Super Bowl, why? It's like when a guy drops to the ground and is rolling but winds up barely grazing the kicker's toe as the kicker jumps 4-foot high to avoid the hit, yet the penalty still gets called.
As far as the punting penalty, I'm not gonna act like I'm up on the rules. I'm relatively new to this whole football thing and I freely admit that, but it seems to ME (right or wrong) that if a personal foul happens before the punt is fielded, it should be corrected and given back to the punting team. That was a really crappy call, whether or not it was within the rules.
And the roughing the passer call was just Ben doing the acting bit as well as he could. Dude got a slight push and went to the ground like someone karate kicked him. Nothing more to say than that really. The way he writhed in pain for about 3 seconds, I probably would've thrown a flag too.
But like I posted a few minutes ago, none were necessarily game-changers and I'm not complaining that AZ should've won. I don't even care that they didn't. But a number of plays/penalties could've been the other way.
QUOTE(DrAndy @ Feb 1 2009, 09:15 PM)

Harrison was lucky he wasn't tossed. What he did was a little excessive.
Yeah, "a little excessive" is an understatement. Dude punched him on the back, then forearmed him to the ground, the punched him again as he got up. Shit, that gets you DQ'd in a boxing match, much less a Super Bowl.
Had the Steelers lost, that guy might've gone the way of Escobar in '94.