QUOTE(Aficionado @ Nov 3 2009, 01:45 PM)

I've said it once and I'll say it again. V for Vendetta was incredible. I loved it. As a standalone flick (not considering the original novel) what didn't you like about it?
Watchmen was awesome how it was.
Another reason why reading sucks. If you can't even enjoy a movie afterwards, what good is reading then?

The book took two contrasting ideological points (facism and anarchy) and busted ass to explore them, inspired by Moore's reaction to Thatcher but not overwhelmed by it and had a much darker tone. The movie was paint by numbers, watered down conservatism v. liberalism and too bright. It didn't have to be. It could have been bad ass visually (it was often anyways) and still gone deep. The Wachowski's, as proven in the Matrix sequels, are too shallow and stupid to pull it off and so, for me, the movie sucked.
Movies and books can be fine...as alluded to before, I thought From Hell was handled well on screen by making a movie and not pretending to be faithful to the source. I liked most of Watchmen until the end...the end was a cop out and totally gutless. Not as bad as V...that was so bad I wanted to kick something. The thing with V is that it would have been so easy to make it right.
Sin City was an AWESOME use of source material. Best I ever saw for the genre.
Those are just comics...other books have been well adapted and some have not. The ones that work usually work because people can walk away going I liked both because they were different and worked in their medium. V wasn't different enough so the vapidity going on was too noticeable.